Truck & Gearhead

Garmin vs Rand McNally Truck GPS: Which Routes Better?

Garmin dezl vs Rand McNally TND compared: truck routing accuracy, map updates, dash cam, truck parking data and which belongs on your windshield.

Updated August 20, 2026

Both of these are built for the same job, which is keeping a 13 foot 6 vehicle off roads it will not fit down. They differ in the details rather than the fundamentals.

The verdict up front

Buy the Garmin dēzl OTR710 if you want the cleaner interface and the larger, easier-to-read screen, which genuinely matters when you are checking a turn at speed. Garmin’s truck parking and loading dock information is well regarded, and the interface will feel familiar to anyone who has used a Garmin before.

Buy the Rand McNally TND 750 if you want the built-in dash cam and prefer their approach to truck-specific points of interest. Rand McNally has been in trucking since long before GPS existed, and their routing reflects that.

What actually matters in a truck GPS

Entering your truck profile correctly is more important than which device you buy. Height, weight, length, axle count and hazmat status all feed the routing, and a default profile routes you like a car.

Neither device removes your responsibility. Posted signs govern, and every low bridge strike investigation finds a driver who followed a screen instead of looking up.

Cost that is easy to miss

Map updates, subscription features and dash cam storage all add to the running cost. Work out the three-year cost rather than the purchase price, in the same way you would for anything else on the truck. Our cost per mile calculator is built around exactly that habit.

If you have narrowed it down to one device, we review each of them on its own terms: the Garmin dezl OTR720 is the size most cabs actually want, the Rand McNally TND 750 is the fuel-price routing argument, and the Garmin dezl OTR1010 is what the 10-inch screen costs you.

GEARPICK

The two truck GPS units drivers actually cross-shop

These are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. We feature gear that fits owner-operators and truck owners; we do not claim to have hands-on tested every item. Prices and availability change on Amazon.

Frequently asked

Can I just use a phone for truck navigation?
No, and this is how drivers hit bridges. Consumer navigation apps route cars. They do not know your height, weight, length or hazmat restrictions, and they will happily send you down a residential street with a 12 foot 6 clearance. A truck-specific device or a paid truck routing app is not optional equipment.
Do truck GPS maps need updating?
Yes, and it matters more than on a car unit because restrictions change. Check what each maker charges and how long updates are included, because a cheap device with expensive updates is not cheap.
Is the routing actually accurate?
Both are good and neither is perfect. Treat any device as an assistant rather than an authority: your own eyes on the posted signs are the final check, and the driver is the one who gets the citation.

TruckingCalc provides free educational information and estimates, not tax, legal, accounting, or safety advice. Rules and rates change; verify anything that affects your taxes, compliance, or safety with a qualified professional and the official source. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.